Foolproof Basque Burnt Cheesecake

Apr 27, 2022 · By Tu · Last updated: Nov 29, 2022 · 35 Comments · This post may contain affiliate links

This foolproof Basque burnt cheesecake is the only recipe you need. It has a super creamy texture, intense caramelized layer on top and beautiful cracklings on the side. Follow my easy-to-follow instructions & cooking tips for 100% satisfaction guaranteed.

a whole basque burnt cheesecake put on a parchment paper — Foolproof Basque burnt cheesecake

Maybe you've known by now, or perhaps you haven't, but I am crazy about cheesecake. Another version of this Basque cheesecake is this creamy blueberry burnt cheesecake.

Besides a classic cheesecake, I like trying different types of cheesecake such as light un-bake Japanese tofu cheesecake or super creamy Greek yogurt cheesecake.

Back to this recipe. The first time I saw this unique, one-of-a-kind cheesecake in a store, I was like: what is it, and how does it taste? I bought a slice, and from that day, Basque burnt cheesecake forever took my heart.

I spent a lot of time testing this recipe, so that you might find this post a little long for a cheesecake. Because I want to add as much helpful information as possible, don't skip any part if you wish to such foolproof Basque burnt cheesecake.

What is Basque burnt cheesecake?

Basque burnt cheesecake originally was made by chef Santiago Rivera, who runs the famous bar-restaurant La Vina in Spain.

The cheesecake has broken all rules of a traditional cheesecake. Burnt top, crackling & unsmooth sides with falling structure.

Differences between Basque burnt cheesecake and New York cheesecake

New York cheesecake is a little more creamy, dense, definitely does not look burnt and has smooth sides. It also has a crust normally made from Graham crackers or cookies.

Basque burnt cheesecake, on the other hand, has a lighter texture and no crust. It also has beautiful cracklings on the sides, and its structure tends to collapse or fall toward the middle of the cake. Like a soufflé, I might say.

Never miss a recipe. Subscribe!

This foolproof Basque burnt cheesecake is:

Made from just 7 ingredients and one of them is even optional.
Versatile because you can never go wrong or fail to make this cheesecake.
Unbelievably creamy and delicious.
Perfect for any occasion from day-to-day eating to a holiday gathering, it'll do an excellent job.
Super beautiful that it can be an ideal centerpiece for any celebration.

Don't be intimidated that cheesecake is impossible to make at home, especially one looks like this. On contrary, cheesecake in general and this one alone, are both achievable at home.

Cheesecake is easier to make than cake because all ingredients go in one bowl. You don't need to separate the batter and incorporate it later like sponge cakes. Just make sure you take time and read thoroughly the complete instructions, especially the cooking tips part; you can quickly achieve this caramelized-top cheesecake.

one slice of Basque burnt cheesecake put on a dark green plate

Essential ingredients

Cream cheese: I used original Philadelphia cream cheese (3 blocks). Not whipped cream cheese or cheese spread.
Eggs: 3 large eggs should do the job perfectly.
Sugar: some granulated white sugar brands just are just more refined and more accessible to incorporate than the others. I love this brand when it comes to baking.
Salt: only ¼ tsp of Kosher salt is needed.
Heavy cream: the regular, liquid heavy cream and not the already whipped cream.
AP flour or cake flour: you can go with either one. There will not be much difference between the two since only a small amount is called for (⅓ cup).
Vanilla extract: this ingredient is optional. I made my Basque cheesecake without one, and it still tasted delicious. If you use vanilla extract, pick the purest, not the blended one.

Overview: mixing steps

Combine softened cream cheese and sugar and beat on medium-low speed with the paddle attachment.
Turn off the mixer immediately and let the cream cheese soften at room temperature if it can't be whipped smoothly, like in the top right photo.
Add one egg at a time, followed by heavy cream, salt, and vanilla extract. Make sure the batter is completely smooth before adding more ingredients.
Carefully add flour to the mixture and mix until everything is fully incorporated, approximately 30 seconds.

Check the batter and ensure it is smooth and free of lump. If in doubt, you can strain the batter through a colander (don't use too fine sieve mesh).
Grease the pan, both bottom, and sides, with softened butter.
Line the whole pan with two layers of parchment paper. Grease with butter in between 2 layers as well as lightly press them against the pan to make them stay in place.
Pour batter into the pan, then use a spatula or the back of a spoon to smooth out the top.
Don't worry about the wrinkled parchment because this Basque burnt cheesecake doesn't suppose to have smooth sides like traditional ones.

Never miss a recipe. Subscribe!

How long should I bake this cheesecake?

I use an 8-inch, nonstick, springform baking pan with removable bottom for this recipe with the removable bottom pan. I bake the cheesecake for 40 minutes, so my cake is semi-soft in the middle and soft toward the outer edge. The top of the cake is also lightly sunken (around 1 to 2 inches).

You can let the cake bake longer (45-50 minutes) if you want a more dense texture or shorter (30-35 minutes) if you wish to have more gooey, oozy souffle-style cheesecake.

Tips for making a foolproof cheesecake

Make sure your cream cheese is completely softened at room temperature before baking. It'll take 1 to 2 hours for blocks of cream cheese to reduce their temperature. You can't whip these up if they're often 100%.
Other ingredients should also be at room temperature, including eggs and heavy cream, to have a smooth, silky, and creamy texture.
Turn off the mixer immediately if your cream cheese cannot incorporate smoothly with sugar. Let the cheese soften at room temperature for a few minutes before continuing the creaming process.
Always sift your flour when making cheesecake.
The cheesecake is baked at a very high temperature (400F - 205C) to create such caramelize effect on top and a sinking structure in the middle.
Don't open the oven in the middle of the baking process. The oven door should be closed entirely to maintain the required temperature.
The maximum baking time you can go for this 8-in Basque burnt cheesecake is 50 minutes. Go any time longer. You might end up with curdled/scrambled-egg-style cheesecake.

How to cool this cheesecake?

Place the cheesecake on the kitchen counter to cool down at room temperature. It'll take 4-5 hours for it to cool down completely. To speed up the process, you can put the cheesecake in the chiller after 1 hour of sitting at room temperature. Only use this if you wish to serve cheesecake right away.

Storage tips

Make sure the cheesecake is completely cool down before storing it as follow:

This Basque burnt cheesecake can be kept under refrigeration and completely covered for up to 1 week.
The cheesecake can be kept frozen for up to 2 months. Make sure to wrap the entire cheesecake (don't remove the parchment and the bottom of the springform baking pan) or each slice in a few layers of plastic wrap.

Never miss a recipe. Subscribe!

More dessert recipes

Did you make this recipe? If so please leave a rating and let me know how it went in the comment section. Also, don't forget to tag me #cookmorphosis @cookmorphosis on social media.